Mets Possibilitites
Since we know where the flaws are with this New York Mets team (Pitching/Age/Management), and which ones they are unwilling to change at this time (Management), I figured I’d make a list of options for the positions in most need of change.
Starting Pitching
All of us are expecting the inevitable departure of Tom Glavine to create the second vacancy in the starting rotation. Even before the beginning of the ‘07 season, the talk had been directed toward two names to fill in one of those spots- Dontrelle Willis and Johan Santana. There are a few more names on that list.
So, in order, here are the guys who I feel can correct the pitching staff.
Aaron Heilman- A great talent. A true team player. A heralded starter in Notre Dame. A few years removed from a complete game 1-hit shutout as a starter for the Mets. And he got better. Omar and Willie can’t go into panic mode. Ignore the mass public filled with the “trade anyone” approach. The answer to at least one of the starting rotation woes is wasting away in the bullpen.
Dontrelle Willis-With the future of the Marlins dependent upon an agreement for a new stadium (which looks grim), there is little doubt that the Florida team will have to shed one of the two contracts which make up over half of their payroll. Look at the career numbers for them both (Willis and Cabrera); it’s a no brainer that when push comes to shove, it will be Dontrelle Willis who is traded. It all depends on how the Marlins try to sell the D-Train’s value.
It won’t cost the Mets anywhere near the amount of talent it would have last year, but it will cost them a pair of guys like Kevin Mulvey and Mike Devaney. And after seeing them dangle him for a set-up man, I don’t believe it will cost anything more than a singular prospect like Phil Humber. Not my favorite move, but last year it would have been both Humber and Pelfrey, as well as Gomez or Milledge. It’s amazing what one year can do to a player’s value huh?
Johan Santana- While Johan is clearly the best semi-available option, he will cost the Mets far too much in prospects. A lot of us already feel that offering Milledge, Gomez, Humber, Pelfrey, and Heilman is far too much. So think about any three of them included with the phenom shortstop Jose Reyes. It’s not worth it right now. Wait until he hits free agency months before Citi Field opens it’s doors. That’s when you make the best offer for him.
Gagne, Wood Dotel- I’ve said this before, but it does bare repeating. With the free agent relief core looking very promising, Something has to be done. Acquire any of these guys to take Heilman’s place, in addition to the return of Duaner Sanchez, and the demons of the pitching staff would be exorcised. What do they have to lose?
For those who don’t know my particular stance on value; I don’t believe that a talented starting pitcher is worth more than a talented position player. There are chances for the position player to effect the game every game, while the pitcher is every fifth day. As dominant as he may be, I would take Jose Reyes’ game changing ability any day over a Johan Santana. Considering he is what the Twins would start negotiations with, it’s not even worth talking about a trade to them. So mark Johan Santana as “highly unlikely” on the list of pitching solutions.
First Base
Carlos Delgado- I understand that he has one more year on his contract. My suggestions fell on deaf ears before the season started (Actually before his first 5 minutes as a Met were official). As it is now, he is virtually untradable due to his putrid year. However, don’t expect him to play the same at all in ‘08. It’s his contract year, and he will be a year removed from his surgeries which clearly hampered his performance a great deal.
Doug Mientkiewicz- Enough can’t be said about the importance of defense at this demanding position. Since Delgado is still under contract for next year, who better to platoon with him, and help groom the next first baseman in the coming years? Be it Mike Carp or who I feel should start taking grounders at the position-Fernando Martinez, Doug Mientkiewicz should be given a 2-3 year deal to keep this position sure handed for the changing of the guard.
Darin Erstad- I’m not sure what his stance is on the Mets now, but it used to be that he didn’t want any part of it. Winning has an effect on these kinds of players. So does money.Both he and Mientkiewicz are stellar fielders and quality hitters. The only concern is how he would adapt to being a par-time 1st baseman/outfielder.
Second Base
David Wright- This is a very temporary solution to the position which would only occur if Alex Rodriguez lands with his favorite NY team. We all know that Wright had expressed his willingness to shift to switch his position in the event of such a blockbuster acquisition. Now I say temporary solution because if A-Rod lands with the Mets, Wright will switch to the other hot corner as soon as Delgado’s contract is expired.
Mind you I love the way David Wright plays third base. I would like for him to get some throwing kinks worked out, but I can see Wright turning into a Biggio type of second baseman. If he wants to stay at the position, Mientkiewicz can hold down the fort easily and groom Carp/Martinez. If Wright wants to switch, Mientkiewicz could groom him to be the first baseman of the foreseeable future. It’s not a bad position to be in at all.
Kaz Matsui- I said it was a mistake to let him go, and he proved in Colorado that he could indeed play at a far higher level. All he needed was a little more time. Looking at the free agent options for second base, there are none that are better than Kaz. Assuming the A-rod thing doesn’t come to pass, the Mets should swallow their pride and give him a new contract. He doesn’t have to play a full-time role. He can platoon with Gotay improving every game.
Luis Castillo- Luis had surgery on his knee and is expected to be ready for spring training. Does that sound convincing to you? No? Me neither. As much as I would love to have him back fully healthy, I can’t get the image of him turning into Jose Valentin out of my mind.
Left Field
Carl Crawford- I know that I keep pressing this issue, but the Mets need this guy. His talents are obvious, and the D-Rays would ask a lot for him. If I were Omar I’d find out the parameters they are willing to work with. Trading good talent for him is worth it. It all just depends on how much.
Kazmir was quoted as saying it gets tiring to be the laughingstock of the league, and he wants veteran help. Well he can’t leave until 2010, but I know a certain team that is more than eager to get their hands back on that sure talent a year after Citi Field opens. The way to do that would be to take away top talent from their team now.
Carlos Gomez/Moises Alou- We saw how the platoon situation panned out with Milledge. Although he was more ready than given credit for, Lastings won’t have to worry about that now. He’ll take RF. LF is going to be platooned with Alou and Gomez unless Crawford makes his way, or Fernando Martinez has a ridiculous first half in the minors prompting a quick promotion.
Catcher
Lo Duca/Castro/Hernandez- Any combination with Castro will do this team a great service. Lo Duca provides that fire and leadership, as well as a hometown discount. Hernandez will require trades, but provides a very potent bat and great defensive capabilities. Castro keeps the entire team loose and still provides a great deal of offense despite coming off of the bench.
Speaking of which…
Bench
Moises Alou- Platooning with Carlos Gomez in LF is a must in order to do two things. Develop Gomez into a full caliber major leaguer, and to keep Moises off of the DL. His bat was so crucial to the team after coming back from his injury and they would do well to keep him around since he wants to come back.
Marlon Anderson- I don’t think I can stress enough how important he is to the team. No need to even explain. You all know.
Tony Clark- Bring back the guy who was wearing Mr.Met’s number. He is a switch hitting first baseman with good power and a good glove. A quality veteran presence that keeps the bench very strong.
Damion Easley- After doubting his worth to the team when he was acquired, it’s easy to see how good of a pinch hitter he is. He came through in the clutch so many times and they were really hurt when he went down. His talent has to be a gift awarded to him for being born a month after the Mets’ first world series victory. Ok, that’s fishing for some kind of connection, but it’s not impossible. After seeing this ‘07 season fall apart, I know that anything is possible.
Well, that’s what I have for you all. Those are my solutions while still holding true to keeping a balanced budget, a good mix of homegrown talent, and veteran stars. Glavine, Green, Alou, Castillo, Lo Duca, Castro, Valentin, Conine, and Sele come off the books this winter. That’s nearly $50 Million that is freed up to teak the roster. While a few guys are going to be returning, most of them will be getting pay cuts. A year later, Delgado, Pedro, and El Duque come off the books. Depending on how healthy Pedro is, he’ll be back, but I can’t see him earning what he does now. That’s nearly $40 Million the Mets can invest into the Johan Santana sweepstakes. We’ll see how things pan out.
The Mets have been very silent since the end of the season. Just like the calm before a storm, the Mets are building up something fierce. Expect them to make very effective changes to walk into Citi Field as the defending World Series Champions.







6 Responses to “Mets Possibilitites”
October 29th, 2007 at 8:53 pm
Gagne/Wood/Dotel/Sanchez - Do you own stock in the NY Hospital for Special Surgery?
Also it would be difficult to platoon Alou and Gomez since they are both right handed hitters.
Gomez should be in the minors. He is very talented but he has a lot of aspects in his game that are completely undeveloped, his pitch selection, approach at the plate, working the count is lacking, he struggled when he needed to lay down bunts. His decision making on the basepaths was questionable. I like him, but he is very raw. He needs to learn in the minors where teaching comes first. Like Ron Darling said repeteadly this year, fans and some baseball people think the minor leagues are a punishment. They sre not. It is a place to learn how to play the game, where instruction is done constantly, where they take fielding drills daily, where they work on bunting drills regularly.
Alou should have his iption picked up, Chavez and Marlon Anderson will prove more than adequate as fill-ins. I would like to see Alou start about 110 games at LF, Chavez about 35 games in LF, 35 games in RF, 15 games in CF. Milledge start about 120 games in RF. Beltran about 145 games in CF, Anderson getting the balance of the starts at the corners.
That is a nice mix of power (Beltran, Alou), line drives (Milledge, Anderson, Alou), contact (Chavez, Alou), speed (Chavez, Milledge, Beltran) fielding (Beltran, Chavez).
Honestly if you can trade Gomez for a really solid SP, I’d do it.
November 1st, 2007 at 12:11 pm
Hey Eric,
I’ll give you Dotel for this conversation. As often as Wood had been injured, it was due to them trying to keep him as a starter. He successfully pitched in August and September; posting a 3.33 era in 24.1 innings pitched, with 24 strike outs. Yeah he walked too many, but I think it would be foolish of us to forget how dominant he actually is. Given more time as a reliever, and a better staff around him, I think Wood can be a premier set up man.
Gagne pitched in 54 games after two injury-ridden years posting a 3.81 era, striking out 51, and marking 16 saves. That kind of production would be far greater than that of Mota or several others on the team.
52 saves in 2002, 55 in 2003, and 45 in 2004. Adding someone who flat out knows how to pitch, but into a set-up/closer’s role can only help this team. Especially considering that they need a right-handed dominant arm in the pen.
With Gomez, yeah, he is raw. But he is a very talented player who showed he can learn quickly on the fly. He actually proved to be one of the better drag bunters on the team. The tandem of he and Reyes on the base paths kept many teams off balance. His glove and range is extremely impressive. His only flaw is pitch selection. He strikes out too much.
Now while the minor leagues is normally the place where prospects would get the most time to improve on their craft, Gomez helped this team far more than hurt them in his big league stint, while learning a great deal. Unless the Mets make a lure Bernie Williams to platoon with Moises, and take the place of Shawn Green, I think Gomez should be up there to add outfield depth.
You and I would love Moises Alou to play in 110 games, but that isn’t going to happen anymore. He played in 87 games last year due to a strain….A strain…. Let’s face it; he needs to have far more rest. I feel that’s why he was so productive at the end of the year. He had so much more time to rest his body; in comparison to how he would be stressing himself through the daily rigors of traveling to the games and playing.
Marlon Anderson really shouldn’t be used to handle the additional outfield assistance. Check Ben Johnson’s ability, or make a push for Bernie if he’s still wants to play.
November 1st, 2007 at 2:08 pm
Your such a moron, after Doug Mientkiewicz left he bad mouthed the mets and Willie Randolph.
November 2nd, 2007 at 9:54 am
Matsui has not done appreciably better than he did while a Met, with the exception of RISP, which many feel is due to luck anyway. Before he was traded, he was doing poorly. He spent a lot of time in AAA after the trade to Colorado. He had a nice NLDS and NLCS, but did little in the WS.
No chance he is brought back.
As for Gagne, yeah, he had a good run from 02 - 04. But not so much lately. He didn’t adjust to the set-up man role in Boston. Why should he adjust here?
Wood is intriguing. A move to the pen full time may allow him to stay healthy, and perhaps Petersen can help with his control. A one year deal might be worth it.
No to Minky.
November 2nd, 2007 at 5:10 pm
“Hey”,
I would love to see any quoted reports of Doug Mientkiewicz saying any such thing.
All Doug ever said since his departure from the Mets, and arrival to the Yankees was that playing with the Mets prepared him for the pressured city. He wasn’t mad at the Mets for deciding to go with Mike Jacobs at the end of the year. He was barely hitting over .200 when the move was made to start Jacobs daily.
Ed, with Gagne, money talks. He did say that he wanted to win a World Series. That was the only reason why he accepted the trade to Boston. Well, that and cash considerations. Gagne is worth landing. The Mets could have had him regardless of his no trade clause had the Dodgers pulled the trigger. Given his track record as a reliever, he is more likely, and more reliable than Wood.
As far as Doug Mientkiewicz, I think he would be extremely reliable, as well as far more successful a second time around with the Mets. How is it ever a bad thing to land a gold glove, hard-nosed contact hitting team player? It’s not. That’s the thing.
November 7th, 2007 at 12:18 am
Seriously you are such a pathetic case for a writer. Let me pull that story out of my A55 thats yeaers old now. It was on the news, watch it sometime.
Leave a comment