MVN - a Baltimore Orioles blog | The Voice of Oriole Fans since 2005!
Oriole Magic
MacPhail Speaks On The Roberts Trade Rumors; We’re Told The Obvious…
Here we have the news that we all pretty much pretty much have surmised; thus, now it has come from Orioles’ COO Andy MachPhail himself.
Our second baseman Brian Roberts, isn’t likely to go anywhere before the season begins.
From the Sun’s Jeff Zrebeics’s piece, MacPhail: “Roberts Deal Unlikely Before Opener”
“Orioles president of baseball operations Andy MacPhail acknowledged today that it is unlikely that All-Star second baseman Brian Roberts will be traded before Opening Day.
“I’ve mentioned to Brian that I think it’s unlikely that something happens,” said MacPhail. “I think with each passing hour at this point, it’s less and less likely. As we get this close [to Opening Day], the greater likelihood is that we’re going to start [the season] with what we have.”MacPhail has been in trade talks with the Chicago Cubs about Roberts for several months, but the two sides were unable to agree on a package. The Cubs made a four-player offer of infielder Ronny Cedeno, pitching prospects Sean Gallagher and Donald Veal and a fourth prospect, believed to be pitcher Jose Ceda. However, the Orioles were looking for a fifth player.
Asked if the talks with the Cubs have reached an impasse, MacPhail said, “I don’t really like to characterize our discussions with other clubs. I’ll leave that to somebody else.”
I really thought this deal was going to get done; however, as Spring Training went on, it looked like it was not going to happen just because the chatter between the two clubs had slowed.
Well, I figure that MacPhail did not like what he was offered, and the Cubs might have grown frustrated.
Right now, Brian Roberts is more valuable as a commodity than actually a player on the Orioles. It remains to see what happens during the season, and if Brian Roberts gets off to hot start, expect the chatter to continue.
Alas, he if gets injured — it’s a whole different story.
In my personal opinion, this deal had to get done to infuse new blood into the Baltimore franchise.
As great as Brian Roberts is as a player and community guy, I think the Orioles might have blown a golden opportunity to restock the minor leagues.





4 Responses to “MacPhail Speaks On The Roberts Trade Rumors; We’re Told The Obvious…”
March 27th, 2008 at 9:37 am
“As great as Brian Roberts is as a player and community guy, I think the Orioles might have blown a golden opportunity to restock the minor leagues.”
Looking at the three together (Tejada, Bedard, Roberts), Roberts is the guy we needed to trade the least. At least, the guy that needed to be moved the least before the season started.
MacPhail’s in the driver’s seat here and he’s acting like it. The Cubs aren’t the only team that may need help at secondbase. The Mets could stand an upgrade, the Dodgers perhaps if Jeff Kent’s injury lingers.
We’ll be a bad team with Brian or without him. If these other team’s are serious about contending, they’ll pony up. I still expect Brian to be gone in July.
March 27th, 2008 at 10:19 pm
Agreed. The Os need to get a ransom. BRob is the last player that will bring more than a modest return - Ramon, Millar, Huff, Trachsel, Walker or Bradford could be traded at the deadline if they have good first halves, but the compensation probably wouldn’t be a Top 10 prospect.
Is there a single page that will bring together the daily box scores, game descriptions and standings of all the Os minor league teams? I want to go to one page each day for my Os-future-fix, since I don’t think I’m going to want to read about the previous day’s Os game very often this year.
March 28th, 2008 at 8:40 am
I respectfully disagree. I am all for trading Roberts but I think we want quality and not quantity. There is no potential blue chipper in that group of players from the Cubs. Are we just stock piling bodies? Gallagher is known to be a potnetial #4 or #5 starter one day. I think we have dozens of those right now. Wait til the deadline and maybe do better.
March 28th, 2008 at 10:56 am
I agree with chip. PIE OR BUST. dont put all your chips in the luke scott barrel, it might not pan out
Leave a comment