November 13, 2008

Rookie QBs Ryan and Flacco are making the grade

There are dangers inherent in selecting a quarterback in the first round of the draft. Vince Lombardi once commented on first-round draft picks,

    "If you make a mistake on a player, you lose some games. If you make a mistake on a quarterback, you get fired."
The Falcons and Ravens didn't make mistakes when they drafted quarterbacks in the first round of the 2008 draft. Rookie quarterbacks Matt Ryan and Joe Flacco have both helped transform losing teams into winners and are both leading candidates for Rookie of the Year honors.

It doesn't always work out that way. The 49ers used the first pick in the 2005 draft on Alex Smith, a move which backfired in their face and got Mike Nolan fired, making Lombardi prophetic yet once again. Smith has lost his starting job, hasn't taken a snap yet this year and hasn't started a game in over a year. He's won only 11 of 30 games as a starter, not what you'd expect from a number one draft pick. Eleven wins in four years! Ryan and Flacco both have a chance to match that win total in just one year.

Smith isn't the only young first-round quarterback who hasn't performed as well as expected recently. J.P. Losman, Vince Young and Matt Leinart, all former starters, are sitting on the bench, watching someone else lead their teams to winning records.

Those who think that Ryan and Flacco stepped into good situations are incorrect. Both came to teams with losing records last year and with rookie head coaches installing new systems which the entire team had to learn. Quite a difference from Ben Roethlisberger's situation in his rookie year, when he stepped in on a team good enough to win a Super Bowl.

Ryan's 89.9 passer rating is eleventh in the league and Flacco's 79.7 is twentieth. They both have a 6-3 record and they've both proved they belong in the NFL.

Here's a look at the career stats of all the quarterbacks drafted in the first round in the last five years.

    Career Stats Gms Strts Comps Attmpts Prcnt Yards Avg TDs Ints Rating
    Matt Ryan 9 9 149 250 59.6 1,909 7.6 11 5 89.9
    Joe Flacco 9 9 151 243 62.1 1,649 6.8 7 7 79.7
    JaMarcus Russell 12 9 141 282 50.0 1,662 5.9 8 8 65.9
    Brady Quinn 2 1 26 43 60.5 284 6.6 2 0 95.5
    Vince Young 31 29 434 761 57.0 4,855 6.4 22 32 68.3
    Matt Leinart 18 16 275 491 56.0 3,209 6.5 13 16 71.2
    Jay Cutler 30 30 589 946 62.3 7,114 7.5 47 30 88.6
    Alex Smith 32 30 435 800 54.4 4,679 5.8 19 31 63.5
    Aaron Rodgers 16 9 217 347 62.5 2,453 7.1 14 6 89.9
    Jason Campbell 29 29 536 897 59.8 5,957 6.6 30 19 81.9
    Eli Manning 66 64 1,157 2,086 55.5 13,311 6.4 91 70 75.5
    Philip Rivers 45 41 754 1,220 61.8 9,042 7.4 65 33 91.0
    Ben Roethlisberger 65 64 1,051 1,675 62.7 13,355 8.0 94 65 90.1
    J.P. Losman 38 31 510 858 59.4 5,847 6.8 32 30 77.9

Tags: Atlanta Falcons, Baltimore Ravens, NFL

Discussion

1 Comment on "Rookie QBs Ryan and Flacco are making the grade"

#1

user-pic

Posted by wacko jacko, November 14, 2008 1:06 PM

Ryan more than Flacco has become a profound force of talent and leadership. Flacco is proficient and smart, but at this point he is more susceptible to being sacked or forced out of the pocket, as he is not able to move or read his coverages as quickly as Ryan. Good news for Ravens fans is Flacco's continuous improvement in executing his role assignments. Plus, Flacco throws a deeper, longer ball than Ryan when necessary; if given the time to stand in the pocket, Flacco could emerge as a better passer than Ryan. What Ryan brings to his team is a better capacity than Flacco to escape bad plays and to individually bring his offense to new life. Flacco's best hope is achieving excellence as a pure passer, reminding us of a young Dan Pastorini, Roman Gabriel, or ---dare I say---Joe Namath.

Reply

Leave a comment