December 1, 2008

Packers Blow Rodgers' Comeback Bid

Aaron Rodgers did all he could, but that won't stop the haters out there from laying all the blame for this loss on him.

I apologize for bringing my issues to everyone, but you don't have to listen to these people frothing at the mouth. You don't have to defend a quarterback who is among the top ten in the game in his first year of starting from vitriolic and irrational personal attacks.

I liken their attitude to this quote from Robert DeNiro as Alphonse Capone in the four-star movie classic, The Untouchables: "I want him dead, I want his family dead, I want his house burned to the ground!"

I am reminded of the deplorable actions of Packers fans who allegedly poisoned Dan Devine's dog in retribution of his failings in following a legend, Vince Lombardi. Unlike the hatred directed at Rodgers, which is unwarranted based on his performance, Devine did not do well as a coach, much less in filling Lombardi's shoes.

But to poison a man's dog? If they did do that, there is a special Hell for them.

I do not expect to see an action like this out of anyone, but within the Packers online community, I have heard people call him a pedophile and make him directly responsible for Brett Favre being traded. There have been questions about his manhood, his leadership, his character...

So you'll have to forgive me my baggage, and there are now two articles I have to write. The first one will detail why Rodgers IS a leader AND the right choice for the Packers under center, the other detailing why Favre has been every bit the quarterback Joe Montana was.

But for now I will focus on this game. Since the haters want a scapegoat, I will provide one: Rock Gullickson, Strength and Conditioning Coach.

The Packers have had nearly 30 players appear on the injury report since final cuts. Out of a roster of just over 50. If you play for the Packers, you have over a 50 percent chance of being injured. At some point, we must accept that this is not bad luck, but due to something we are or are not doing.

If the offense sputters, you replace the offensive coordinator. If the defense sputters, you replace the defensive coordinator, unless it is because you are missing two starting linemen, your best linebacker, two safeties and a cornerback.

Then you fire the strength and conditioning coach, NOW! After all, how much worse could we do in the last month without one? Two more Packers went down in today's game, and one of them I did not even know, meaning he was so far down on the depth chart but playing because so many of those in front of him are hurt.

Rodgers had a slow start to this game, missing on his first four passes with three of them sailing high. But I remind everyone that this was the modus operandi for Favre in his first few years.

And just like Favre, Rodgers bounced back, completing 29 of his last 41 passes for 298 yards and three touchdowns. Granted he threw a pick that all but ended our chances, but he did it trying to force a play with his back deep in our own end and a four point deficit late in a game. Again, just like Favre often did, so you are getting what you asked for.

The Packers rushing attack also worked, with Ryan Grant (12 carries, 39 yards) being replaced by Brandon Jackson (11-80) because he was too effective to take out of the game. In all, Green Bay ran 29 times for 145 yards (5.0 average).

But again, the defense let them down. Carolina rushed 27 times for 130 yards (4.8 per carry) but had five touchdowns. Jake Delhomme threw only 17 times, completing 12 for 177 yards, but that included a near-touchdown with the Packers up three points in the final two minutes that all-but ended the Packers chance to come back in the wind and snow.

Nick Collins also played the role of Jarret Bush in last year's NFC Championship Game, slowing to get an angle to pick up a loose ball around the Packers' three yard line rather than just falling on it. Twice balls hit defenders in the hands and they failed to come up with the interception; the Packers lost the turnover battle 2:1.

They also lost the special teams battle. Our kick coverage was awful, with Mason Crosby being forced to be in on two tackles on big returns, the last one setting up Carolina's winning drive. Derrick Frost continues to punt inconsistently, making the release of Jon Ryan all the more inferiating (I originally typed "inferiorating," which is an obvious Freudian slip).

Which leads me back to a scapegoat. Often, beligerent fans want to hang this season's failure on Ted Thompson. But they do it for the wrong reason: it was not the trading of Brett Favre that ruined our season.

It was the trading away of Corey Williams, who might have provided us needed depth on the defensive line to absorb these injuries. It was the drafting of injury-prone Justin Harrell way too high in the first round. It was the choice to cut an effective Ryan and pick up Frost. It was the failing to bring in any free agents to bolster a team that was a player and a play away from a title run last year.

Those are legitimate reasons to question the reigning NFL Executive of the Year.

(I originally wrote this article for Bleacher Report.)
Tags: Aaron Rodgers, Brandon Jackson, Brett Favre, Green Bay Packers, Jake Delhomme, NFC North, NFL, Ted Thompson

Discussion

4 Comments on "Packers Blow Rodgers' Comeback Bid"

#1

user-pic

Posted by Joseph, December 2, 2008 12:15 AM

I look forward for those two articles. You still spelled infuriating wrong (inferiating is how you spelled it). Derrick Frost apparently is going to be released.

It's too bad that we aren't switching to Brandon Jackson as the starter for at least next game, I would think that some time on the bench would allow Ryan Grant to think about how terribly he is playing.

Extremely intelligent and captivating article as always.

Reply

#2

user-pic

Posted by Mark, December 3, 2008 4:08 AM

What about your defensive coordinator? How can a defense that yields just a field goal to a decent Bears team get walloped and abused the very next week? Maybe blitzing once in a while would help. The defensive line is inept when it comes to rushing the passer. People who blame Rodgers for the Packers' season of futility are clueless and probably had unhappy childhoods.

Reply

#3

user-pic

Posted by MJ Kasprzak in reply to comment from Joseph, December 3, 2008 4:50 AM

Thanks for the correction--I'll take care of that. I guess I didn't notice it because my mind had originally been on the word inferior. And thanks for the read and kind remarks.

I wouldn't say Grant is playing terribly--he has gotten up to about 900 yards after a VERY slow start, and has gotten to 100 yards in three of five games, I think. But I would like to see Jackson be given the start--he's been impressive in little action and I'd like to see what he can do given more.

Reply

#4

user-pic

Posted by MJ Kasprzak in reply to comment from Mark, December 3, 2008 4:56 AM

Mark, you are right about the clueless people with unhappy childhoods, or some kinda issue. Sanders has been on-again off-again as D-coordinator, much like McCarthy's oversight of the offense--hence our huge performance against one team and horrible one against another. And while I agree with you that more blitzes are in order, I understand not wanting to put our depleted coverage on an island. But I also figure if what you are doing is not working, you need to do something else--i.e. no doubt we should have tried it more the last two weeks.

Reply

Leave a comment